Loading

SME Financing for Biodiversity: Building Nature Measurement and Impacts into SME Financing (‘SME FinBio’) A Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) funded project, carried out by Middlesex University

A project carried out by the Centre for Enterprise, Environment and Development Research (CEEDR)

Watch our project summary presentation (less than 10 minutes) - or scroll down for more information about the project's scope, key findings and how to contact the team for more information

Project overview

As the Dasgupta Review (2021) highlighted, business and nature must work together...

The project focuses on the biodiversity reporting challenges in the financing of UK small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and examine ‘nature positive’ financial risk assessment related to SMEs

Research Aim: to examine what processes and frameworks might inform the development of UK SME market impact risk assessment

RQ1: What approaches to SME biodiversity impact measurement can be used in reporting and risk assessment for financiers?

RQ2: What incentives can effectively encourage SME biodiversity reporting?

Understanding the role of SMEs in delivering gains in carbon reduction and biodiversity enhancements

  • Biodiversity is a driver for climate change: protection and restoration of the environment can also mitigate climate change. However, there is no route map for green SME finance in the UK.
  • SMEs represent 60% of private sector employees and over half of GDP (BoE, 2020). However, there has been no research on ‘nature positive’ linked financial risk assessment related to SMEs.
  • There is massive heterogeneity of SMEs (notably their different sector, materiality and resource bases), making a 'one-size-fits-all' reporting framework difficult.
  • Small (<50 employees) and Micro (<10 employees) companies in the UK have exemptions from auditing their financial report and submitting a director’s report to the Companies House, under the FRS 105.
  • UK SMEs (< 500 employees) are not currently required to formally report their climate or wider environmental impacts.
  • SMEs struggle with the burden of reporting and may lack incentives to consider their biodiversity impacts. UK government is highly cautious concerning additional reporting /‘red tape’.
  • Most SMEs are laggards that don't act due to cost and other priorities (BBB/IPSOS SME Survey 2021). Nearly half of UK SMEs are not aware of Government green energy efficiency support programmes (45% of UK - LSBS, 2021).
  • Climate and Biodiversity (nature-based) impact reporting are challenges for UK SMEs and their finance markets - public, private, funding insurance risk assessment.
  • UK Government financing instruments (e.g. BBB, UKRI) offer only recent and minimal guidance for Climate Change (BBB report, 2021) with no consideration for Biodiversity and potential negative impacts from Climate Change actions.
  • UK green growth productivity (Clean Growth Strategy, 2017), Green Finance Strategy (2019) and its Green Finance Institute, pay relatively little attention to SMEs as innovators and innovation adopters.
  • As such, SME consideration of and reporting on biodiversity remains virtually non-existent.

There is a call from SMEs and market support services for greater incentivising of green investment. It is important to raise SMEs’ understanding of climate change and specifically biodiversity impacts and the benefits of self-reporting – particularly in higher-risk sectors.

Two key types of green SME investment angles

(i) investors in SME innovators (SMEs that are developing green/environmental innovations)

(ii) SME innovation adopters (SMEs who wish to invest in adopting new green innovations)

Whether SMEs are innovators or innovation adopters, improved metrics are required to improve risk perception and calculate the environmental economic value of the innovation (Harrer and Owen, 2022).

Central Bankers recognise ‘sweet spot’ of convergence between climate, biodiversity and society – Central Bankers mandate to act, develop, advise – driven by concerns of over UN ’30x30’ - 30% land and sea conservation required by 2030.

However, SMEs are in a perilous situation in the current UK and global economic turmoil, meaning that capturing such value needs to be simple and cost-effective.

Understanding green financing processes

Longer horizon larger pension fund investors make decisions with 10+ years of future consideration. Banks typically finance through medium-term loans 3-7 years; Long horizon early-stage SME innovation investors (impact accelerators, angel networks and seed VCs) are at the cutting edge of assessing disruptive environmental impacts. The British Business Bank, IUK and BEIS are all major SME funding departments/agencies.

Motivations and drivers for financiers

What is the TNFD?

A market-led, science-based TNFD framework aimed to support companies and financial institutions to integrate nature into decision-making risk management and financial disclosures

Funded by government and philanthropic grant-making including the UK (DEFRA), French, Australian, Swiss and Dutch governments, the Children's Investment Fund Foundation, the Global Environment Facility (GEF) and UNDP

The TNFD has released V0.2 of the TNFD beta framework, which is now out for market consultation

The TNFD Forum is a multi-sectoral network of over 650 institutions exploring best practice on nature-related risk management and disclosure trends

Videos

For more information

  • Dr Robyn Owen (PI) r.owen@mdx.ac.uk
  • Professor Fergus Lyon for agri-food case study f.lyon@mdx.ac.uk
  • Dr Amy Burnett a.burnett@mdx.ac.uk
Middlesex University, CEEDR/GreenFin, The Burroughs, London NW44BT

Credits:

Created with images by thithawat - "green plant growing on golden coin in glass jar on wood table in park with blur nature background. business financial banking saving concept. investment profit income. marketing startup success." • coco - "honeybee,butterfly and lady bud on lavender flowers in panoramic view" • onephoto - "SME or Small and medium-sized enterprises" • sarayut_sy - "growth business. The tree grows into a shape, pointing up the concepts of financial business growth."