Abstract
We apply a critical perspective on leadership development discourses and practices to the case of student leadership development programs in the US universities and colleges. We leverage the first author’s personal experiences as a facilitator in such programs to focus on the manner in which they adapt and deploy a variety of commodified pop and positive psychology techniques—including prominently among them icebreakers and psychological assessment tests—that encourage participants to share personal and emotional insights about themselves as the necessary prerequisite for becoming leaders. We draw on Foucault’s notion of pastoral power to argue that these quasi-therapeutic practices help to produce and to normalize what we describe as a confessional culture of leadership development that prepares would-be student leaders to submit themselves to similarly or even more psychologically demanding regimes of governmentality in the workplace after they graduate. We conclude with a call for future research on the central role of such leadership development practices—and the institutions, industries, and actors that promote them—in folding together the ways that individuals seek to claim agency and to develop themselves as leaders with the ways that organizations function to constrain that agency and to govern them as willing but compliant subjects.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, S. J., & Hartman, N. S. (2009). Sources of learning in student leadership development programming. Journal of Leadership Studies, 3(3), 6–16.
Alvesson, M., & Kärreman, D. (2000). Varieties of discourse: On the study of organizations through discourse analysis. Human Relations, 53(9), 1125–1149.
Alvesson, M., & Willmott, H. (2002). Identity regulation as organizational control: Producing the appropriate individual. Journal of Management Studies, 39(5), 619–644.
Anderson, G. L., & Grinberg, J. (1998). Educational administration as a disciplinary practice: Appropriating Foucault’s view of power, discourse, and method. Educational Administration Quarterly, 34(3), 329–353.
Asplund, J., Agrawal, S., Hodges, T., Harter, J. & Lopez, S. J. (2014). The Clifton Strengthsfinder® 2.0 technical report. Gallup. Retrieved January 3, 2020, from https://rgdoi.net/10.13140/2.1.3408.7366.
Avolio, B. J., & Gardner, W. (2005). Authentic leadership development: Getting to the root of positive forms of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 16(3), 315–338.
Barr, K. Jr. (2013). Building a strengths-based campus. CliftonStrengths Coaching Blog. Retrieved January 10, 2019, from https://coaching.gallup.com/2013/10/building-strengths-based-campus.html.
Bell, E., & Taylor, S. (2003). The elevation of work: Pastoral power and the new age work ethic. Organization, 10(2), 329–349.
Besley, T. (2005). Self-denial or self-mastery? Foucault’s genealogy of the confessional self. British Journal of Guidance and Counselling, 33(3), 365–382.
Besley, T., & Peters, M. (2007). Subjectivity and truth: Foucault, education, and the culture of self. Counterpoints. New York: Peter Lang.
Blithe, S. J. (2019). “I always knew I was a little girly”: The gendering of skills in management training. Management Learning, 50(5), 517–533.
Boler, M. (2004). Feeling power: Emotions and education. New York: Routledge.
Butler, N., Delaney, H., & Spoelstra, S. (2017). The gray zone: Questionable research practices in the business school. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 16(1), 94–109.
Caldwell, C., & Hayes, L. A. (2016). Self-efficacy and self-awareness: Moral insights to increased leader effectiveness. Journal of Management Development, 35(9), 1163–1173.
Carroll, B., & Nicholson, H. (2014). Resistance and struggle in leadership development. Human Relations, 67(11), 1413–1436.
Case, P., & Phillipson, G. (2004). Astrology, alchemy and retro-organization theory: An astro-genealogical critique of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator®. Organization, 11(4), 473–495.
Chlup, D. T., & Collins, T. E. (2010). Breaking the ice: Using ice-breakers and re-energizers with adult learners. Adult Learning, 21(3–4), 34–39.
Clifton Strengths for Students. (2019). Student leadership development, Vanderbilt University. Retrieved January 6, 2020, from https://www.vanderbilt.edu/leadership/programs/cliftonstrengths/.
Collinson, D. (2011). Critical leadership studies. In A. Bryman, D. Collinson, K. Grint, B. Jackson, & M. Uhl-Bien (Eds.), The Sage handbook of leadership (pp. 181–194). London: Sage.
Collinson, D. (2012). Prozac leadership and the limits of positive thinking. Leadership, 8(2), 87–107.
Cvetkovich, A. (2003). An archive of feelings: Trauma, sexuality, and lesbian public cultures. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Day, D. V., Fleenor, J. W., Atwater, L. E., Sturm, R. E., & McKee, R. A. (2014). Advances in leader and leadership development: A review of 25 years of research and theory. The Leadership Quarterly, 25(1), 63–82.
Dugan, J. P. (2017). Leadership theory: Cultivating critical perspectives. San Francisco, CA: Wiley.
Ecclestone, K., & Hayes, D. (2009). The dangerous rise of therapeutic education. New York: Routledge.
Eich, D. (2008). A grounded theory of high-quality leadership programs: Perspectives from student leadership development programs in higher education. Journal of Leadership and Organizational Studies, 15(2), 176–187.
Fairclough, N., Mulderrig, J., & Wodak, R. (2011). Critical discourse analysis. In T. A. van Dijk (Ed.), Discourse studies: A multidisciplinary introduction (2nd ed., pp. 357–378). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Fairhurst, G. T. (2007). Discursive leadership In Conversation with leadership psychology. Los Angeles: Sage.
Fejes, A. (2011). Confession, in-service training and reflective practices. British Educational Research Journal, 37(5), 797–812.
Fejes, A. (2016). The confessing academic and living the present otherwise: Appraisal interviews and logbooks in academia. European Educational Research Journal, 15(4), 395–409.
Ferry, N. C. (2018). There’s a leader in you!: A critical mapping of leadership discourse in the American university. Doctoral Diss., Washington State University, Pullman, WA.
Finch-Lees, T., Mabey, C., & Liefooghe, A. (2005). ‘In the name of capability’: A critical discursive evaluation of competency-based management development. Human Relations, 58(9), 1185–1222.
Ford, J., & Harding, N. (2007). Move over management: We are all leaders now. Management Learning, 38(5), 475–493.
Foucault, M. (1982). The subject and power. Critical Inquiry, 8(4), 777–795.
Foucault, M., Burchell, G., Senellart, M., Ewald, F. & Fontana, A. (2009). Security, territory, population: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1977–78. Retrieved June 13, 2019, from https://public.eblib.com/choice/publicfullrecord.aspx?p=736155.
Fry, L. W. (2009). Spiritual leadership as a model for student inner development. Journal of Leadership Studies, 3(3), 79–82.
Gagnon, S. (2008). Compelling identity: Selves and insecurity in global, corporate management development. Management Learning, 39(4), 375–391.
Gagnon, S., & Collinson, D. (2014). Rethinking global leadership development programmes: The interrelated significance of power, context and identity. Organization Studies, 35(5), 645–670.
Gehrke, S. J. (2008). Leadership through meaning-making: An empirical exploration of spirituality and leadership in college students. Journal of College Student Development, 49(4), 351–359.
Ginsberg, B. (2011). The fall of the faculty. New York: Oxford University Press.
Goucher College. (2020). Leadership resources: Teambuilding. Retrieved from https://www.goucher.edu/experience/getting-involved/leadership/documents/Team-Building.pdf.
Guthey, E., Clark, T., & Jackson, B. (2009). Demystifying business celebrity. New York: Routledge.
Helping Kids Have Great Lives Starts With Focusing On What They Do Best. (2020). Clifton StrengthsExplorer. Retrieved January 3, 2020, from https://www.strengths-explorer.com/home.aspx.
Hinz, K., Stubblefield, R. & Soria, K. (2012). Strengths at the U: Creating a strengths-based undergraduate experience. The University of Minnesota. Retrieved January 6, 2020, from https://conservancy.umn.edu/handle/11299/157256.
Hunter, I. (1994). Rethinking the school: Subjectivity, bureaucracy, criticism. Questions in cultural studies. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
Illouz, E. (2008). Saving the modern soul: Therapy, emotions, and the culture of self-help. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Jenkins, D. M. (2013). Exploring instructional strategies in student leadership development programming. Journal of Leadership Studies, 6(4), 48–62.
Kellerman, B. (2012). The end of leadership. New York: Harper Business.
Kempster, S., & Stewart, J. (2010). Becoming a leader: A co-produced autoethnographic exploration of situated learning of leadership practice. Management Learning, 41(2), 205–219.
Kiersch, C., & Peters, J. (2017). Leadership from the inside out: Student leadership development within authentic leadership and servant leadership frameworks. Journal of Leadership Education, 16(1), 148–168.
Kohn, S., Walsh, D. & Souza, J. (2003). Team challenge course and mobile initiatives manual. Retrieved from https://venture.uncc.edu/sites/venture.uncc.edu/files/tcc-mobile-manual.pdf.
Komives, S. R., & Wagner, W. (2017). Leadership for a better world: Understanding the social change model of leadership development. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Kouzes, J. M., & Posner, B. Z. (2014). The student leadership challenge: Five practices for becoming an exemplary leader. San Francisco, CA: A Wiley Brand.
Kouzes, J. M., & Pozner, B. Z. (2006). Student leadership practices inventory: Facilitator’s guide. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Lasch, C. (1991). The culture of narcissism: American life in an age of diminishing expectations. New York: Norton and Company.
McCuaig, L., Öhman, M., & Wright, J. (2013). Shepherds in the gym: Employing a pastoral power analytic on caring teaching in HPE. Sport, Education and Society, 18(6), 788–806.
Nadesan, M. H. (1997). Constructing paper dolls: The discourse of personality testing in organizational practice. Communication Theory, 7(3), 189–218.
Nicholson, H., & Carroll, B. (2013). Identity undoing and power relations in leadership development. Human Relations, 66(9), 1225–1248.
Nicholson, H. (2011). The undoing of identity in leadership development. Thesis, The University of Auckland Business School, Auckland, New Zealand.
Petriglieri, G. (2011). Identity workspaces for leadership development. In S. Snook, N. Nohria, & R. Khurana (Eds.), The handbook for teaching leadership (pp. 295–312). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Petriglieri, G., Wood, J., & Petriglieri, J. (2011). Up close and personal: Building foundations for leaders’ development through the personalization of management learning. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 10(3), 430–450.
Pfeffer, J. (2015). Leadership BS: Fixing workplaces and careers one truth at a time. New York: Harper Business.
Rath, T., & Conchie, B. (2008). Strengths based leadership: Great leaders, teams, and why people follow. New York: Gallup Press.
Sinclair, A. (2011). Being leaders: Identities and identity work in leadership. In A. Bryman, D. Collinson, K. Grint, B. Jackson, & M. Uhl-Bien (Eds.), The Sage handbook of leadership (pp. 508–517). London: Sage.
Sixth College at the University of California, San Diego. (2019). Icebreakers, team building activities, and energizers. Retrieved February 11, 2019, from https://sixth.ucsd.edu/_files/_home/student-life/icebreakers-teambuilding-activities-energizers.pdf.
Sixth College at the University of California, San Diego. (2019). Leadership tip sheet. (2020). Goucher College. Retrieved from https://sixth.ucsd.edu/_files/_home/student-life/leadership-tip-sheets.pdf.
Smolović Jones, O., Grint, K., & Cammock, P. (2015). Public leadership development facilitation and the crossroads blues. Management Learning, 46(4), 391–411.
Sugerman, J., Scullard, M., & Wilhelm, E. (2011). The 8 dimensions of leadership: DiSC strategies for becoming a better leader. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.
Tennant, M., McMullen, C., & Kaczynski, D. (2010). Teaching, learning, and research in higher education: A critical approach. New York: Routledge.
Townley, B. (1993). Foucault, power/knowledge, and its relevance for human resource management. Academy of Management Review, 18(3), 518–545.
Trilling, L. (1955). Freud and the crisis of our culture. Boston: Beacon.
Vernon, F. (2014). The paradox of structured autonomy. Other Education, 3(2), 22–44.
Wildemeersch, D. (2014). The confessing society: Foucault, confession and practices of lifelong learning. International Journal of Lifelong Education, 33(1), 107–111.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare they have no conflict of interest.
Ethical Approval
This paper does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.
Informed Consent
This paper does not contain any studies with human participants or animals and therefore required no informed consent.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ferry, N., Guthey, E. Start ‘Em Early: Pastoral Power and the Confessional Culture of Leadership Development in the US University. J Bus Ethics 173, 723–736 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-020-04565-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-020-04565-7